1. When Simms ranks RBs or defenses, where oh where will the Packers be? ************************************. Wentz Trevor Lawrence is the most coveted quarterback prospect in recent memory. Without him, they would be 4-12 or 5-11 every year. Good decision maker, good in the pocket, and a leadership and moxie that is rare for a backup. I mean, that could be a part of the equation. 27, and there isn't an edge-rusher worthy of this pick. Name another coach with 5 walk off postseason losses? The Patriots have their next Solder sitting at No. Its not an easy exercise. Wilson ahead of Brady and Ben? ESPN, ABC, and NFL Network will air all seven rounds of the 2023 NFL Draft. Allen is a similarly electrifying talent who has led his team to the playoffs two out of three years as a starter. 1 draft pick, Chris Simms shakes up his quarterback rankings, Report: Derek Carr wants $35 million per year, Mike McCarthy: Kellen Moore wants to light the scoreboard up, I want to run the damn ball, The Raiders are the betting favorites to land Aaron Rodgers, ESPN reiterates report that Lamar Jackson wants a fully-guaranteed deal, Arrest warrant issued for Jalen Carter for reckless driving, racing, Aaron Rodgers says hell make a decision soon enough, Competition Committee begins to explore the quarterback push play, Players say Chiefs discourage them from reporting injuries, have NFLs worst training staff, Report: Jalen Carter was present at teammates fatal crash, misled police about it. He's like Michael Vick. These two picks, however, didnt quite pan out, as Fenimore played only 10 games and Harmon opted to leave professional football for a career in Hollywood and duty in the U.S. military during World War II. . Dallas can use him to attack downfield, but it can also use him on screens and speed-sweeps and even out of the backfield. 1. suckafree9rs415 says: 2: Simms continues to have his all-time favorite quarterback, Aaron Rodgers, at No. Plus, the Lions have to face plenty of quarterback talent in the NFC North. 1 QB. The California native completed 152-of-270 passes for 1,812 yards, 16 touchdowns and six interceptions. Mayfield is a pure thrower, and he'll have no issues cutting through the winter weather in Buffalo. He is easily one of the top interior linemen in the draft, and he got a lot of useful experience playing in Iowa's pro-style offense. He has a great base, always keeps his feet under him and churning and won't be overpowered. Chris Simms ranks the top 16 quarterbacks Posted by Mike Florio on August 23, 2018, 11:09 AM EDT Getty Images Last year, Chris Simms made waves by putting Jaguars quarterback Blake Bortles at No. The question I'm asking if I'm in charge of the Ravens is who'll be our next Terrell Suggs? Think of Payne as a young Kawann Short. However, I wouldn't go quarterback if I'm Miami, and I'm not mocking trades, so Buffalo gets its man. He also had 92 carries for 204 yards and five touchdowns. This is a no-brainer pick for the Tennessee Titans. ====== The Buccaneers had the league's 32nd-ranked pass defense last season. Pretty strong arm. Vince Williams was OK, but he wasn't good enough in a Steelers defensive scheme that places heavy importance on the position. Not a member? "You get to see everything. Bryan reminds me of a poor man's J.J. Watt or Michael Bennett in terms of power and agility at the point of attack. The event will be held at Union Station, which is located near the citys World War I Museum and Memorial. 1 quarterback, there is a lot to like about Allen. I don't see a superstar in Ridley, but he can be a very, very good receiver, and he can be one from Day 1. Smith can be Oakland's version of Vontaze Burfict. Ive never actually made a list of my top 50 quarterbacks of all time so I dont know if Phil Simms would made the list or not, but I do know you have to be a complete clueless clown to make a case for a guy who played in the 80s and 90s by comparing his career statistics to a guy who played in the 50s and 60s. Brian Orakpo, 31, and Derrick Morgan, 29, are getting up there in age, and the Titans lost Avery Williamson in free agency. You cant play football on your daddys name. I wish he wasn't so robotic, his improvisation does not match his athleticism. With Jordy Nelson in Oakland, the Green Bay Packers could go wide receiver here. What better way to win over some of the L.A. fanbase than to draft the Southern California darling Darnold? He'll be in an offense that knows how to utilize all his skills, and he'll have other weapons around him to command defensive attention. lol @ Andrew Luck. Without Brady, the Pats dont come back from a 28-3 deficit against the Falons. Matthew Stafford fourth? You must be logged in to leave a comment. Wilson has to figure out how not to get killed again this year. They're going to grab Penn State running back Saquon Barkley, and that's what I'd do as well. But he posses many of the traditionally desired characteristics of a great quarterback. Enjoy this year because you may be looking at an era of not having a Pro Bowl QB AWW what a shame.. I could see the Atlanta Falcons looking at a tight end at No. Therefore, I'd address a piece of the offense that's been missing since the team traded Jimmy Graham in March 2015a pass-catching tight end. Tennessee now has Mike Vrabel as its head coach, and I think Vrabel will look for a linebacker who reminds him of himself. Luck Rounds two and three will commence Friday at 7 p.m. On Monday, March 29, Chris Simms sat down with Paul Burmeister to discuss his top cornerbacks and safeties ahead of the 2021 NFL Draft, scheduled to take place on April 29-May 1, 2021, in . Whether Washington decides to play him as a true strong safety or as an extra linebacker, his physicality and aggressiveness are going to shine through. He's a tremendous football player, and he can do anything you ask him to along the interior defensive line. Learn how your comment data is processed. Ultimately, though, they'll pull the trigger on Notre Dame tackle Mike McGlinchey. Arizona is also a perfect situation for Jackson. Chris Simms: Sam Darnold is the fifth best quarterback By Josh Edwards Apr 2, 2018 0 Chris Simms spent eight seasons playing in the NFL with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Denver Broncos and. 6. While Daniels primarily played center in college, he did play some guard and appears willing to play the position in the NFL. Coverage of the latest news from around the NFL is available all year round on PFTs Peacock channel. Seattle Seahawks (via the Denver Broncos), Philadelphia Eagles (via the New Orleans Saints), Houston Texans (via the Cleveland Browns), New Orleans Saints (via 49ers, by way of Broncos and Dolphins). Does he still have Garoppolo in the top ten? But this is a results business. But of course Vikings fans and Pats fans know more about QBs than Chris Simms who played the position and learned the position from his father who happens to be one of the Top 50 QBs ever. Spoiler: Bortles didn't make it. Last year, Chris Simms made waves by putting Jaguars quarterback Blake Bortles at No. Jimmy G will rip this list to shreds. The Bills need a franchise quarterback, and they'll get one in Mayfield. The New Orleans Saints don't have many big weaknesses. Dallas will be able to use him immediately, and he could become a top-five NFL wideout in a couple of years. However, consensus has been hard to come by with regard to the dual-threat talent. Georgia's Isaiah Wynn is the perfect fit for the Buffalo offense. The 2023 NFL Combine takes place on Thursday, March 2 through Sunday, March 5 at Lucas Oil Stadiumhome of the Indianapolis Colts. 2) Brady Wilson ahead of Brady and Ben? He has an explosive first step and great hand usage, and he's a force at the point of attack. People have it wrong if they think he has the biggest bust potential. He'll help improve the Raiders' second-level coverage and has the speed to make a quick path to running backs and receivers when the ball is in their hands. Moore is the right pick here. Rivers Similar to Big Ben, hes getting long in the tooth. 13. Josh Allen, 5.) "This kid is not just a straight-ahead runner. Kinda sick of this Chris Simms revisionist gospel. I won't predict trades because, well, that's just as silly as pretending to know what teams are thinking. Allen completed just 56-percent of his passes over the last two seasons. The Vikings had more injuries than the Packers and went 13-3. So McCarthy is good enough to get them that far but when they come up short its always on him and Rodgers can do no wrong? Evans reminds me of Ravens linebacker C.J. On the latest episode ofThe Simms & Lefkoe Podcast, Simms said he's seen enough from Jackson over the last two seasons at Louisville to believe he has all of the traits necessary to succeed at the next level. 13. Luck should not be on the list at all. Vander Esch is athletic and versatile enough to play both inside and outside, and he fits the New England-style scheme coordinator Dean Pees is likely to run. The Dolphins could go quarterback here, but if I'm in charge, I'm sticking with Ryan Tannehill and addressing other needs. RELATED:What Colts offer to Bears for No. 14. I wish Vander Esch was a bit more physical, but that often develops at the pro level. Now if you are talking about who has been better all time thats different. Chris is really salty. Hes toward the bottom as a thrower of the football, and hes careless with the football," Simms explained. You can see who did by checking out the segment, and you can chime in with your thoughts regarding the sanity or lack thereof regarding his selections in the comments. B/R's Matt Miller currently ranks Jackson as hisNo. Rodgers He fights for his life every season and doesnt win when it counts. Rodgers is saddled with the second coming of Marty Schottenheimer. The Rams made the playoffs, have a young, exciting signal-caller in Jared Goff and added a bunch of wonderful pieces in free agency. Posting Freak. Book it. I see Aaron paving the way for all these great up and coming QBs. 319 prospects representing over 100 schools will showcase their skills and athletic ability in front of the leagues coaches, scouts, and team owners. He gets upfield, and he disrupts. That's going to open things up for Elliott and the run game. In this situation, though, I have to go with the guy who's most pro-ready and can help Cam Newton immediately. 17, but I have several concerns about him. I am pretty sure Chris Simmss favorite QB of all time is Phil Simms. __________ When Seattle was making its Super Bowl runs, it had standout linemen like Russell Okung, James Carpenter and Max Unger. Drafting Payne would add both youth and talent at an area of need for Cincinnati. The most pressing need, though, is at cornerback. Pittsburgh has a massive hole at middle linebacker, left after Ryan Shazier went down. Too many people are sleeping on him. Yes, the team picked up Antonio Garcia in last year's draft, but he was injured before the season and remains a question mark because of blood clots. QB #36 Tyrod TaylorA backup I like, but I wish you could depend on him to stay healthy. He'll also be ready to play in Week 1. The last time Chicago picked first in the NFL Draft was 1947, when they selected halfback Bob Fenimore. ET. But he's not in the trust tree. His arm might not even be as good as Bridgewater, but he knows how to play. August 23, 2018 at 11:33 am Hows that roster coming along? Mayfield is the definition of middle of the pack with the 3rd highest floor and 4th highest upside.Lamar Jackson has amazing upside but has a decent chance of busting. Mike Florio and Chris Simms during the 2018 NFL . He's also strong and stout enough to play nose tackle in Cincinnati's scheme and make a mess of things at the line of scrimmage. Here goes: 1. This year, Simms has gotten started with the top 16. After Rodgers. He has a lot of talent, throwing for 3,692 yards and 33 touchdowns last season. In recent years, however, the line has been a joke, and Russell Wilson has been running for his life. He was also a pro quarterback, so there's that too. Register now! He's an elite athlete with fluid hips and great change-of-direction in coverage. 16. He is that gifted of a runner.". He had the best Wonderlic score among top quarterback prospects, has elite size at 6'5", 237 pounds, has elite athleticism for that size and has as an arm that is John Elway-esque. However, they have guys they've drafted, and I believe Cincinnati will give them at least one more year to develop. Well, that isn't what you'll find here. Tittle? 1 and No. But NO WAY Rodgers is #1! See below to find out who made the top 5 names for each position. That is why Notre Dame's Quenton Nelson is an easy choice at No. If the Cardinals want to throw him in sub-packages as a runner or a receiver as a rookie to get him used to the speed of the game, that's great. 3. This is where Ward comes into play. I think it'll be tough for Kenny Pickett to beat him out.#SimmsTop40, #26 Jameis WinstonPerformed under a ton of pressure last year. The 2018 NFL Draft takes place from Apr. Because cracking the top 16 is a great accomplishment? 8. He checks just about every box. Be sure to subscribe toChris Simms Unbuttonedfor more on the2022 NFL season as well as an unfiltered look at the NFL, featuring player access, unabashed opinion, X&O film breakdown, and stories from a life in and around football. Spoiler: Bortles didnt make it. He has quick hands and can disengage blocks as fast as anyone in the draft. He's a tremendous athlete, he's physical and he'll be able to do everything the Steelers ask him to do. However, I know your reason for posting is simply trying to prove me wrong on something. The hype has been building at a rapid pace since Lawrence's outstanding freshman season back in 2017. 2018 was Simms' most impressive act. What qualifies Chris Simms to rank a quarterback? And they likely get beat by a lot more than 8 points in last years SB. 4 overall selections. 1 selection by the Jacksonville Jaguars. I don't get what's not to like about Chark. ZenMaster. Here are his QB prospect rankings: 2018 Lamar Jackson Josh Allen Baker Mayfield Sam Darnold Josh Rosen 2019 Kyler Murray Drew Lock Dwayne Haskins The top five QBs thus far this season, based on performance weighted by circumstances, are Mahomes, Goff, Brees, Cousins, and Rodgers. However, general manager Bob Quinn and new head coach Matt Patricia both came from the New England Patriots, and I don't believe they value the running back position enough to take one here. I know my good friend Kyle Shanahan loves athletic offensive linemen, and at 33, Joe Staley is getting up there in age. Yes, it could go secondary, but Oakland has drafted safeties the last two years, has Reggie Nelson on the back end and took cornerback Gareon Conley in the first round last year. This will help take pressure off Wilson. He's built a lot like Solder with long arms (34 ) and above-average height (6'9"). Honorable mention: Winston, Goff, Carr and Mariota. He was the only person who had Herbert over Tua last year. Plus, new defensive coordinator Mike Pettine is used to having guys like Darrelle Revis and Joe Haden on an island, which gives him more freedom with his defense. Josh Allen has highest potential of all of them but also has highest chance to bust as he needs a lot and I mean a lot of work on accuracy and decision making. A good week of interviews and workouts could help Jackson gain the traction he needs inside front offices.". Adding him to Carson Wentz on this Eagles offense makes too much sense. August 23, 2018 at 12:09 pm The Chargers can set up their franchise for the future and get the fans going with a guy they're familiar with. "[Moving to wide receiver] is the dumbest f--king thing I've ever heard," he said. At the worst, drafting Vander Esch would give Tennessee a very good 3-4 outside linebacker for years. So maybe he does know what he's talking about and isn't just ranking Lawrence second to drive engagement. 1 overall. Knows how to read defenses and move in the pocket. Brady has had incredible success but hes always had a much better team around him, and certainly better coaching, than Rodgers has had. The 2023 NFL Draft will take place in Kansas City, Missouri. Tittle, so based on your logic, I guess he must have had a lot of great games and belongs in the top 50. 16. Wilson Those two years, their record was a combined 5-12-1 (.306) without Rodgers and 10-4 (.714) with him. cant even get a job right now. 10. He's also the draft's most explosive receiver with the ball in his hands. There's one glaring weakness for the Pittsburgh Steelers, and it should be obvious. He's great against both the run and pass, and he can bring pressure up the middle. Can 49ers fix his accuracy/mechanics?He has the potential to shoot up this list.#SimmsTop40, #30 Jared GoffTougher than he gets credit for, willing to take a hit in the pocket. As will ones that have Mac Jones in the top-3, and Kellen Mond in the top-5. Adding him to one of the top offensive lines and best offenses in the league will make things very difficult on opposing defenses. Brees and Rogers are pretty close behind. I got to watch him in person at every Notre Dame home game last season, and he never failed to impress. I thought some of the crew here on PFT could not get more clueless. Simms had one great game in his life, in the Super Bowl, kind of like Timmy Smith for the Redskins. I could see him as a starter one day.#SimmsTop40, #33 Geno SmithIt's been a long time since his NY struggles. QB #38 Teddy BridgewaterHe is the ultimate backup. If Allen threw 10 passes a game behind the line of scrimmage, we wouldn't be talking about his completion percentage. Is Rosen the ideal prospect from an athletic standpoint? Auburn's Carlton Davis can be that guy. 2. The Packers need elite QB play on free plays and phantom facemask calls to win games. Which is a roundabout way of saying, You should watch it.. Lawrence has been wearing the crown of the Next Big Thing for years. The Packers were 7-9 last year and Rodgers played six full games. Must be nice winning the pre-season SB every year as a Packers fan, but hey, Im happy with the 5 the Pats have gotten during this run. Runs like a slot receiver and can make all the throws. August 23, 2018 at 11:21 am, Viking fans will go nuts which is hilarious. Landry could lead the NFL in sacks a few times in his career, and he's a guy Ravens fans will love. 9. The Detroit Lions could use a running back. I like Roquan Smith for the Oakland Raiders at No. His 2018 rankings were scary spot on. With the real thing just weeks away, its never too early to start putting together mock drafts. It's drafts like these when I'm so glad I'm not our GM, Kevin Colbert. Simms tends to get a lot of hate for going against the tide with his quarterback rankings, but he's had pretty good hit rate so far. His results dont add up to TB12 or Wilson. So McCarthy is good enough to get them that far but when they come up short its always on him and Rodgers can do no wrong? ET on NBCSN. I think his track record speaks for itself. He also came into New England and lit up the Pats on Sunday night football. The New York Jets have reportedly not yet scheduled a pre-draft visit with Darnold. But inconsistent mechanics lead to inconsistent accuracy.He's a game manager w/ a stronger arm. LOL. Florio knows whats up. Wilson, meanwhile, is a fast riser in this year's draft class and nobody outside of draftnik circles heard his name before the calendar turned to 2021 and mock draft season began in earnest. The biggest miss here is somehow nobody has told Simms that you dont button the top button of a shirt unless youre wearing a tie. Otherwise, his measurables and positional versatility will make him a favorite of Vrabel's. [I've] seen him be durable. He'll fit right in replacing Colvin, and with a little seasoning may be able to move to the outside if Jacksonville decides it can't afford Jalen Ramsey or A.J. freefromwhatyouare says: I think the quarterback class is a hair overrated," Simms said via MMQB.com. We dont even know IF he can play a full game now, OR if he even has any arm strength after SHATTERING his Shoulder last year? Chris Simms Position Rankings through the years. This is why Smith can have an immediate impact. I know the Dolphins like Mayfield too, so I won't be surprised if the Bills make a trade to leapfrog them. Eagles. He had the 2nd highest QBR in the league as, I think? Baker Mayfield, 4.) He might not dominate every contest, but there's no weakness to his game. Holding down the fort, but didn't do anything last yr to prove he's the Lions future.#SimmsTop40. You might be surprised to see USC's Sam Darnold available at No. His results dont add up to TB12 or Wilson. I've been around the NFL a long time, and I love putting my experience and knowledge to work during the predraft process. ___________. The 2023 NFL Draft begins on Thursday, April 27 and ends on Saturday, April 29. Green when he came out of Georgia in 2011. He can beat offensive tackles almost any which way you can imagine. Maybe if Rodgers played better he would make his coach look better like Brady does. Hell be on the list by the end of the year, Hell be on the list by the end of the year I am glad Chris Simms pulled his head out of his A*s to do the debate with Florio. 1 spot for the majority of the season, a Texans victory against the Colts ultimately handed the top position to the Chicago Bears. Chris Simms has already started breaking down the top prospects by position on the Chris Simms Unbuttoned podcast. But this is a results business. 2. Based on your reasoning, Kerry Collins is also one of the top 50 QBs of all time. Aaron Rodgers is a fantastic QB, but hes not done nearly enough to be considered the GOAT. If I'm Philadelphia, I'm adding another explosive playmaker at receiver. Vea may carry a lot of weight on his frame, but he's nimble and athletic. When the New York Jets traded up to No. The Vikings aren't especially weak there, but Joe Berger's retirement does create a hole. Vea is a jaw-dropping player, and I wouldn't be shocked if he goes higher. I think doing it for a few seasons ought to count for something. Because of this, they're going to make what I like to call an in-your-face pick. Bleacher Report NFL Analyst Chris Simms evaluates this year's NFL Draft QB prospects. He can break two people's ankles at the same time. Great in the pocket, makes Top 10 QB high-end plays, and ditched some no-risk-it-no-biscuit bad habits. How does Stafford belong in the top 15 but not COusins? Allen has the highest ceiling, and he has the highest floor, too. Not nearly as bold a ranking as the one above, but he was still right. Hes just not the best. The only question was which one would it be? I think hes great though. We've seen snippets, but it never quite gets there. Nelson is as good a guard prospect as I've seen since I got into this business, and he could be in the conversation for the league's best guard in Year 1. He can be a force in the run game, too. He had the best Wonderlic score among top quarterback prospects, has elite size at 6'5", 237 pounds, has elite athleticism for that size and has as an arm that is John Elway-esque. He's on the smaller side, and I'd like to see him react to the ball a little quicker, but he should be a phenomenal nickel corner immediately. Always quick to discount any success and just give it to scheme and coaching. The Chicago Bears have one of the best offensive lines in football, so I don't think they'll go there. In addition, Alexander plays with swagger and loves to get in the face of receivers. That wasn't necessarily an unpopular opinion at the time; the questions about Mahomes entering the draft that year was not about his talent but if he could harness it effectively. Rodgers hasnt had enough good performance on the road or coming from behind to put him ahead of at least 5 or 6 QBs on the all time list despite his unbelieve throwing ability. The Washington Redskins could use another big man in the middle of their defense, but they added Jonathan Allen in Round 1 last year. I could see them going tight end, too. It makes more sense, though, to make a pick that helps them get back to their defensive identity. His ability to keep plays alive contributes to his value. 1 followed by Drew Lock. Discussion I got bored and tried to make a file that shows Chris Simms position rankings over the last several years. The Seattle Seahawks have a number of needs that could be addressed in Round 1, but the offensive line is by far the biggest. I also don't believe receiver will be a priority for executive vice president Tom Coughlin. The Arizona Cardinals could add a variety of players. Now if you taking about who is better all. Rodgers ranked #1. I think Wilson is the closest thing to a young TB12 as you can find. Then you all surprise me once again. What do you mean by that? And you should. The team made the playoffs eight times while he was the owner . With a little guidance from Patriots line coach Dante Scarnecchia, Miller has the potential to be New England's left tackle for years. "The running is the best running I've ever seen from a quarterback other than Michael Vick. Lest we forget, the lead-up to that draft was rife with takes about how Jackson would be better off playing a different position, and he won MVP as a quarterback two years later. He'll provide the same things the Redskins got from Su'a Cravens when he was healthy, but he'll do them better. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The biggest thing they should address is the interior offensive line. When he then says Rodgers is the GOAT, Elway is 2nd and Brady is 3rd, well I think his 5 minutes of fame should be up by now, Rob Brzezinski is a Magician says: Vea's results speak for themselves, and he made for one of the most fun watches in my predraft process. The Cardinals have Sam Bradford and Mike Glennon, so Jackson will have time to develop. Brady He wins, and wins when it counts, with the rings to prove it. Plus he never lets other scouts' opinions sway him and his evaluations. Bleacher Report NFL analyst Chris Simms has Lamar Jackson pegged as the No. Check out the video above to see where he ended up and why. #NBCSports #ChrisSimmsUnbuttoned #NFLDraft2019 Subscribe to NBC Sports: https://www.youtube.com/nbcsports. He's aggressive, has a high motor and a ton of upside. Obviously anyone who is not a complete clueless clown has both Phil Simms and Y.A. Luck should not be on the list at all. 1 on the list, even though hes playing on No. Garoppolo This is why Alabama's Calvin Ridley makes sense at No. The guy played outside in 40-degree Wyoming weather and had terrible talent around him. Dude was a bust QB in the league and a bust analyst. Theres a lot of good quarterbacks in the NFL, Simms said. Baltimore needs to find that guy on its front seven that every other team will fear on a weekly basis. So, what will happen this year? Dont usually watch these but curious if hes always a jerk. Six years prior to Fenimore, the Bears chose Tom Harmon with the No. He's explosive, and he's a good route-runner. What qualifies Chris Simms to rank a quarterback? He can make every throw an NFL team could ask of him, he's accurate, and he isn't going to make drive-killing mistakes often. Brees and Rogers are pretty close behind. Baker Mayfield, 4.) Id go Brady, Wilson, Rodgers but thats just me. Throwing and running, taking both of those into account thats part of the game right now in the 2022 NFL. I don't watch a lot of college football but based on Chris Simms' opinion, my ranking would be: 1.) He can use his speed to get around the edge (he ran a 4.64-second 40 at the combine), and he can power through if the edge isn't there. Josh Allen, 3.) NFL Draft 2020: Chris Simms' Top 5 Quarterback Rankings | Chris Simms Unbuttoned | NBC Sports 67,086 views Mar 24, 2020 529 Dislike Share NBC Sports 2.3M subscribers Chris Simms.