gold hill mesa sinkingwhere is walter lewis now

Search
Search Menu

gold hill mesa sinking

2, El Paso County, Colorado. We have full confidence in the safety of the property as evidenced by the No Action Determination letters provided by the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment with its review of cleanup plan compliance documentation on a filing by filing basis.. conrad.swanson@gazette.com, By Conrad Swanson Rather, out of the nearly 500 homes in Gold Hill Mesa, we are aware of only a. Clemens inspection was not related to lawsuits filed by residents at Gold Hill Mesa. The satellite study was performed by experts at the University of Rome in Italy, which offered the potentially expensive analysis for free, Lovekin said. When the economic grip of World War II took hold, miners were relocated to help the war effort. It stacked 162 images of Gold Hill Mesa captured by satellite cameras between June 2011 and October 2017, tracking the movement of buildings and infrastructure. They resolved the problem and we havent heard of any issues subsequently.. Beautifully built John Laing home complete with five bedrooms, five bathrooms, and an ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT awaits you in the highly desired Gold Hill Mesa Community! I have not seen evidence of excessive settlement of structures, roadway improvements or utilities, or been advised by city officials that excessive settlement has occurred at Gold Hill Mesa, he later wrote to The Gazette. 23220. This property is not currently available for sale. Gold Hill Mesa developers hope a new report validates their assertions that the neighborhood's 500 homes are in no danger of sinking. Several obvious problems were apparently missed by regional building inspectors, he said. City Councilman Bill Murray expressed concern that the developers engineer, rather than an independently contracted firm, was conducting those additional tests. I will check into that and see what is possible., More in Gold Hill Mesa development (2of9), Despite learning more than three years ago that perhaps dozens of homes in Gold Hill Mesa were slowly sinking, heaving and flooding, Colorado . The developer and fellow residents would absolutely crucify anybody who goes against the community, said one woman who lives there. Site identification and general characteristics. Other reports of flooding throughout the development are likely linked to debris stuck in piping, she said. With open arms she was immediately loved and cared for by the neighborhood. The survey data, provided to The Gazette by Gold Hill Mesa, tracked movement at different points in the development. When I arrived, I found standing water in the curbline in front of address, one work order for February 2018 states. Colorado Springs mayoral candidates address affordable homeownership. And in those cases, the developer and homebuilders have been responsive to the neighborhoods needs. (Photo by Katie Klann, The Gazette), A woman walks her dog on Saturday, Aug. 10, 2019 at Gold Hill Mesa. Colorado Springs, Colorado. But without sufficient testing, its unclear what settlement and liquefaction potential exists and whether those extra steps are needed, McLemore said. We thank you, our residents, community supporters, and stakeholders, for supporting that mission by choosing Gold Hill Mesa to be your home and embracing us as a part of the broader Colorado Springs community. Colorado Springs : 100. Photo by Allison Daniell, Stellar Propeller Studio. It's a bright view from stage at a Music on the Mesa concert at Gold Hill Mesa. We are bringing custom, energy efficient homes to Mountain Shadows, Gold Hill Mesa and all of El Paso county for you. Again, CGS reviewed and acceded to this work in 2004. Picture being part of the Pikes Peak Gold Rush during the late 1800's when the former Golden Cycle Mill was the top producing gold mill in the nation with the highest payroll in the state - providing the economic backbone for Colorado Springs and turning the area where Gold Hill Mesa now stands into one of the most illustrious locations in all of Colorado. In recent months, Gold Hill Mesa representatives have hosted seminars on the developments stability, the community and environment. Bryant Consultants offers over 20 years of expertise in geotechnical forensics and site analysis built upon a multi-disciplinary approach for uncovering truths held within soil, materials and . Portions of Gold Hill Mesa sank more than 3 inches over a six-year period, state geologists reported to Colorado Springs planners this April. According to homebuilder Wayne Intermill, owner of Hi-Point Homebuilders, there were. March 2015: RENTED 215 S Raven Mine Dr - Townhome - 1,885 sqf for rent at $1,500 - great space with 2 car garage. CSU determined that it was a water service line leak, she wrote. And the entire site should be tested for its potential for liquefaction, destabilization that could be set off by seismic activity from nearby faults. The Colorado Springs City Council spoke behind closed doors Monday about development at Gold Hill Mesa, where city planners recently halted wo Agency finds sinking at Gold Hill. Throughout this 15-year redevelopment, Gold Hill Mesa has grown into a strong and vibrant community, which is key to our mission of taking this long-dormant and blighted property and improving it through a responsible environmental clean-up plan. Other school options nearby include Giving Tree Montessori School, The Colorado Springs School, and an option to enter the D-12 School District space permitting. Were in a wet period now, and that would make me even more nervous to (continue construction) without additional borings to show whats going on down there, he said.. Colorado Springs, CO Manitou Springs, CO. That wasnt a failure of our (perimeter) drain. The sump pump (has) been working, pumping gallons of water daily, sometimes multiple times a day, out into the alleyway behind our garage, she wrote. Nearby Cities. So the ground now settled or heaved.. Gold Hill Mesa is positioned at the gateway to Western Colorado's finest outdoor recreational areas, with quick access to Highway 24 and I-25, making it an easy drive to some of the best ski resorts and outdoor living adventures in Colorado. Removing the window well on the north east side of the home to scope the French drain in all directions to look for any kind of issue (clogged, smashed). Not until much later in the article is there any mention that the report from 2015 was actually commissioned by a plaintiffs attorney, and the reporter never connected the previous mention of an independent experts report to the fact that it was actually a report prepared for the plaintiffs lawyer. Gold Hill Mesa is close to Downtown Colorado, Old Colorado City, Bear Creek Park, a dog park, and Garden of the Gods. The apparent sinking that has occurred in the development is likely caused by water shifting in the soil at Gold Hill Mesa, hypothesized Virginia McLemore, principal senior economic. Peter M. Susemihl (Designated Election Official Signature On File) A CALL FOR NOMINATIONS (NOTICE BY PUBLICATION OF) 1-13.5-501, 1-13.5-1102(3), 32-1-905(2), C.R.S . 2006: 20061328727 : Gold Lake HOA; Grand Junction: 19. View More Details Address 1545 Gold Hill Mesa Dr is located in Old Colorado City, Colorado Springs. Three-inches of movement can result in cracking of walls, floors, and hard finishes such as tile or rock, Lovekin wrote. When: Sunday, June 13, 2:00 - 7:00 pm Where: 142 S. Raven Mine Drive No such information is known, he wrote. We no longer accept (Villa de Mesa) as a valid substitution for sampling, testing for settlement or collapse, calculating estimates of long-term settlement, or as a reason to approve development where such an investigation and evaluation has not taken place, he wrote. Already, at least three lawsuits alleging structural problems at the site have been settled out of court. Grass and snow and landscaping could impact results, but these guys are looking at the corners of rooftops and other hard targets, Lovekin told The Gazette. As many of you have seen or heard by now, the Gazette published a long article on Gold Hill Mesa in Sundays newspaper. Nearby Neighborhoods. Hoping it stays that way.. View more property details, sales history, and Zestimate data on Zillow. Seismic activity has been recorded relatively recently in and around Colorado Springs. (Displacement is measured in mm. The site has been tested multiple times by a number of skilled and qualified geotechnical firms, including CTL Thompson, since 2004, he wrote in an email to The Gazette. Although he won the case, Olson said, he has yet to receive restitution. Ft. 1,484 Stories Lot Size 1,919 Sq. As a result, we understand that the water pumped out has created some discoloration on the concrete, but this is not corrosion, she wrote. But, Zhou said, the Italian experts behind that analysis could have already accounted for those details. But Hoffmann still argued that the data falls short. Gold Hill Mesa Apartments for Rent Gold Hill Mesa Houses for Rent Gold Hill Mesa Duplexes/Quadplexes for Rent. Asked later whether shed share the videos, Edwards replied: At this point, I am not sure we can or will release a video. Established in 1905, it proudly stood as the most important mill in the region for nearly four decades. Differential ground movement in Gold Hill is clearly indicated, he wrote. "Despite learning more than three years ago that perhaps dozens of homes in Gold Hill Mesa were slowly sinking, heaving and flooding, city planners and regional building staff allowed development to continue uninterrupted, a Gazette investigation has found. We now have an internal policy to not represent buyers or sellers in that neighborhood, Fisk wrote in an email. Simple things that are inconvenient but alleviate the situation so you can continue living there.. . Gold Hill Mesa Heirloom Townhome Association. Replace the downstairs bathroom vanity that was destroyed by the restoration company. For how long, thats another geological engineering question, he said. refi payment: $2,344/mo Refinance your loan Neighborhood details Home value Zestimate $421,200 Zestimate range Representatives of the Colorado Geological Survey and Gold Hill Mesa remain in discussions about an appropriate approach to more testing at the site, city spokeswoman Jamie Fabos said. -70mm 3-inches). We have to know a lot more than we currently know to get that level of confidence.. Im out there digging in the yard all the time. Gold Hill Mesa is by FAR the best community we have ever lived. They found that portions of the site sank more than 3 inches, Lovekin wrote. Dreams inspired. New construction homes from David Weekley Homes are sold out in Gold Hill Mesa. Here you'll find a walkable, close-knit community where there's time to . In a nutshell, our crews believe there were two possible sources for the water complaints on Millstream Terrace a presence of groundwater in the area and a leak that was repaired in June 2018, Steve Berry, a Utilities spokesman, wrote in an email. Repainted the walls after replacing the drywall in the basement. At last check, our home is not sinking . The legacy of Gold Hill Mesa is represented by this land's rich history and a community development worthy of its unique heritage - where the progressive spirit of the early pioneers lives on; and restoration of the traditions from yesteryear are contributing to a new way to live well on Colorado Springs' Westside. Thats true, said Virginia McLemore, principal senior economic geologist at the New Mexico Bureau of Geology and Mineral Resources, who was also asked by the Gazette to review the state geologists report. The new proposed expansion should be tested for settlement risks, he said. The homes at Villa de Mesa have stood strong for decades and indicate that no problems should be expected at Gold Hill Mesa, Hoffman said. At the heart of the Colorado gold rush was the Golden Cycle Mill. The tailings pile under the development is estimated to be 130 feet deep in places. They didnt sample, they didnt test, they didnt do blow counts. Instability has been a chief concern for the site since its inception. Its a big problem.. The design of Gold Hill Mesa provides residents with a close-knit village style community with Old World charm. Here you'll find a walkable, close-knit community where there's time to enjoy an active lifestyle. Edwards, vice president of the Gold Hill Mesa corporation, would not allow a Gazette reporter inside one of the seminars, saying they are only for residents, and a media presence would disrupt the event. The community is full of town-homes and single-family homes. High Plains Ranch MD Jackson Creek North MD Executive Vice President, Gold Hill Mesa -- Building Community, Business & Land Development, Strategic Planning, Marketing Communications, Epic Events Greater Colorado Springs Area 5K followers . Ft. Common sense suggests that if there were issues with the community itself, one would expect challenges with homes to become apparent over entire areas, such that neighboring homes would exhibit similar symptoms, Stephanie Edwards, executive vice president of the corporation, wrote to residents in response to coverage by The Gazette. The seminars have been taped, Edwards said. You actually know your neighbor (in Gold Hill Mesa) and youre close. The apparent sinking that has occurred in the development is likely caused by water shifting in the soil at Gold Hill Mesa, hypothesized Virginia McLemore, principal senior economic geologist at the New Mexico Bureau of Geology and Mineral Resources, who studied the satellite images and the CGS report. And that much movement in six years is quite fast, he said. After John Laing filed for . . Replaced about 3 feet of the basement drywall that the restoration company cut out because of it being wet. That vertical foundation crack was filled with epoxy, and anchors were installed to brace the home further, the repair schematic shows. The delay endangers the successful redevelopment of the site, wrote Stephanie Edwards, executive vice president of the developer, to city planners. Despite pushback from Hoffmann and Gold Hill Mesa, state geologists are holding firm. Colorado Springs mayoral candidates address affordable homeownership. Citing evidence of significant sinking or subsidence of the land under homes elsewhere at Gold Hill Mesa and the lack of sufficient data characterizing land under the planned expansion (dubbed Filing 11), CGS cannot recommend approval of Filing No. Mine tailings are notorious for their instability and settlement potential. Nearly a century later, Gold Hill Mesa is restoring value to this property with a planned community worthy of its progressive history and majestic landscape. Mr. Casey has implemented 100 VCUP projects since 1995, including Stapleton Redevelopment, Pepsi Center, and Elitch Gardens to name a few. Location 1 Aliquots. We are here to serve our clients. Repaired, recaulked, and painted a small water leak in the ceiling where the fireplace jack goes out the roof. When asked by The Gazette, Hoffmann did not respond to Lovekins statement about Villa de Mesa. But outside those two areas, movement elsewhere in town would be relatively minor, Lovekin said. All those who reached out to The Gazette or who were contacted by The Gazette about problems or concerns wanted anonymity because they are worried that voicing such concerns could bring them legal troubles and scorn in the neighborhood. I present whatever information is available give them resources where buyers can do their own research and then the buyers make up their own mind.. The two women and other homeowners track varied lists of homes throughout the development where theyve seen flooding, heard of cracking or other problems. Thanks to the pioneering spirit of the projects developers, supporters and homeowners, the community will serve as homage to the history of Old Colorado City and the Golden Cycle Mill, and as a foray into the next era of sustainable, inspired neighborhood design and urban revitalization. Pushback from area residents is natural and understandable, agreed Zhou, Hoyt and McLemore. I'll really miss my neighbors, but they're only 7 blocks away, so I'll see them regularly. Elliott speaks highly of the sense of community at Gold Hill Mesa and says if state geologists are calling for additional testing to ensure the ground is stable and safe, then the developer should comply. My understanding is that concrete discoloration can also result when irrigation water flows through fertilized areas, she added. You cant tell me the ground isnt moving, she said. Its the only place Ive ever lived where someone will sell one house to buy another house in the neighborhood.. They know on warm summer nights, that when the street lights come on it's time to go home. And Lovekin said understanding the liquefaction risk is pertinent for current and future residents. Gold Hill Mesa is in School District 11, which is supported by Midland Elementary, West or Holmes Middle School, and Coronado High School. Edwards said a water line leak was also discovered in September 2017, near Gold Hill Mesas community center at 142 S. Raven Mine Drive. There was a problem saving your notification. Gold Hill Neighborhood, LLC Info@goldhillmesa.com Alicia Petz 719-900-1461 Community Home Owners Association Manager (HOA) MSI, LLC cpilato@msihoa.com Corey Pilato (719) 260-4548 Colorado. Inspections are required on every filing at Gold Hill Mesa and a No Action Determination request is only approved once CDPHE has been satisfied that the conditions in the VCUP have been met. Public Facts for 1605 Gold Hill Mesa Dr Edit Facts Beds 3 Baths 3 Sq. In order for land to be redeveloped, as has been done at Gold Hill Mesa, CDPHE must approve a No Action Determination.. the separation and sinking of minerals below a silicate shell dur-absorption spectroscopy The observation of a n absorption spec- ing the cooling of the Earth from a liquid stage, . Established in 1905, it proudly stood as the most important mill in the region for nearly four decades. They, too, spoke of the sense of community it offers them. The runoff is already substantial when it rains, said Jay Byram, another West Costilla Street resident. Realtor Nathan Fisk said his team strongly recommended against a client buying in Gold Hill Mesa nearly three years ago and walked away from a $500K+ deal due to their safety concerns. Elliott said she couldnt remember whether that crack was disclosed to her, but she has no structural concerns with the home. (Other residents) are having true issues and its costing them money. Since 1976, David Weekley Homes has put our Customers' needs, desires and requests above all else to fulfill Our Purpose of Building Dreams, Enhancing Lives. 11 , Final Plat-AR FP 19-00201; and Development Plan-AR DP 19-00198; . 1171 Gold Hill Mesa Dr, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 is currently not for sale. But then Harward who lives on South Favorite Street said she spoke with a representative of the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, which regulates the site, determining whether dangerous chemicals exist in Gold Hill Mesas topsoils. Homes built by Covington Homes build community, The Girl Scout Cookie Program feeds entrepreneurial and life skills, 1 dead following overnight shooting in Pueblo, Colorado Springs home prices fall to lowest point in nearly 1 years, Reliever Brad Hand signs with Colorado Rockies, Jamal Murray's big second half serves as last laugh vs. old friend and Memphis Grizzlies, 'Here's looking at you, Congress' | COLUMN, LETTERS: Ducking the real issues; ASC Thrift Shop to close, At Home: Whats hiding in your rugs? Everything points to one thing: shifting, cracking. Water stains the driveway and pavement outside a home in the Gold Hill Mesa Thursday, Oct. 3, 2019. At the height of productivity, the mill processed 1,500 tons of ore per day from the famous Cripple Creek Mining District, turning the area where Gold Hill Mesa now stands into one of the most illustrious locations in all of Colorado. I just got out of there before my house went down the hill. Doors and windows can stop operating properly and floors can become uneven.. Typical for large developments, the 210-acre Gold Hill Mesa (master-planned for about 1,000 homes), is separated into filings. El Paso County Assessor Public Records. In addition, the technology is used by the Colorado Department of Transportation and other organizations throughout the United States and Europe, he said. At the heart of the Colorado gold rush was the Golden Cycle Mill. My basement bedroom flooded again today. Gold Hill Mesa's tree lined streets will greet you with warm fall colors, while a live performance by Rocky Mountain Americana band, Thunder and Rain, provides a soundtrack to the changing seasons. Address: 142 S Raven Mine Dr. # 200, 80905 | Use of this website is subject to, Traditional Neighborhood Development (TND). (Photo by Katie Klann, The Gazette). You would not believe the basement floor, she said. A band of neighbors to the east watch with concern, scrutinizing the development rippling out from the last great infill project on the citys west side. The neighborhood would love to make sure that everything thats built on is safe, but especially the next section that needs to be filled, she said. Theres no way to know what type of material that is.. Asked about the alkalinity noted from the water, Edwards wrote it was explained to me by the community landscape company that this is common when irrigation water drains through clay soils. Today we're learning more directly . What (past engineers) did was: they drilled to bedrock, they burned holes in Villa de Mesa, Lovekin said. The woman said she walks the neighborhood and can see water draining from one house into a nearby alley, even when the weather is dry. Comments are open to Gazette subscribers only. Gold Hill Mesa welcomes and encourages oversight. Because of the history of this property, Gold Hill Mesa has always been highly visible and subjected to scrutiny. Looking out over Gold Hill Mesa, a housing development in Colorado Springs. Style Townhouse Year Built 2012 Year Renovated County El Paso County APN 7414428002 Home facts updated by county records on Oct 24, 2022. Jennifer Elliott said her home on Eclipse Drive, like many others in town, flooded during heavy rains in 2013. Subject: Gold Hill Mesa Filing No. The home is within walking distance of the Bear Creek Open Space with a large, well-maintained Dog Park. The tailings pile under the development is estimated to be 130 feet deep in places. In addition, outliers in the data are generally quite visible and can be discounted. Berry later added that Utilities crews do not think both incidents were attributable to the pinhole leak that was discovered in June, but its difficult to prove without a doubt due to elevated groundwater levels in the area.. And thats what we do. We have lived here for 12 years & just moved to a different house in the same neighborhood. But still he wrote, We contend that this is not a reason to expose additional homes and the public to largely unknown risks from ground subsidence.. He spoke fondly of a summer concert series in the neighborhood and the potlucks that coincide. But nothing indicates that Villa de Mesa sits atop the same type of materials as Gold Hill Mesa, Lovekin told The Gazette. The concert and festival will be held outdoors at the Gold Hill Mesa Community Center Saturday, October 13 from 11:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m. Vote Gold Hill Mesa Best Neighborhood in Gazettes Best of the Springs, Gold Hill Mesa Statement on Gazette Story. If you have any questions or concerns about this story or about any issue in our community, please do not hesitate to contact me at info@goldhillmesa.com. Another woman, who formerly lived on Eclipse Drive in Gold Hill Mesa, said, The whole thing was a nightmare and we were only there a year. And the basement there was left discolored after water flooded in, she said. Comments are open to Gazette subscribers only. But several residents interviewed by The Gazette outlined cracks, flooding and other problems theyve had with their homes or saw in others. Homes for sale in Gold Hill Mesa are newer homes built from 2010 to today with a median sales price of $340,000. As this vibrant community has taken shape, it is difficult to imagine that the land it occupies sat dormant for over half a century. Cleaned debris from the trench drain in the patio area. Construction has been halted on one section but continues on others. I want out of the neighborhood, but I dont think that itll be very easy, she added. Looking out over Gold Hill Mesa, a housing development in Colorado Springs, on Saturday, August, 10, 2019. And thats the way many of the residents like it. Risk for damage is most pronounced in areas where the ground is heaving or sinking at uneven rates, Hoyt said. You can see its corroded.. The developer paid for the repairs, Edwards wrote. Colorado Springs, CO - The 99th running of The Broadmoor Pikes Peak International Hill Climb, brought to you by Gran Turismo, kicks off on Sunday, June 13 at Gold Hill Mesa's Music on the Mesa - a free family event, open to the public. We received the latest CGS letter responding to CTLs response this morning and, as we always have, we will continue to work to address the questions CGS has raised. Access all of our premium content, get unlimited digital access and more! Is comparing Colorado Springs' and Denver's homeless populations fair or unfair? September 14, 2022. Yes, I'm a fan of Gold Hill Mesa and a resident. Tracking pre-existing damage could be difficult, but the data still indicate a defamation or landslide movement, she said. Looks like hipointbuilders.com is safe and legit. Yes.. Several residents acknowledged flooding in their homes but say those issues are linked to heavy rains and possible homebuilder defects rather than any problems with the stability of the soils. April 2015: 1480 Gold Hill Mesa Dr - 1,363 sqf, about $1,450. Theyre typically attracted to the area for its location and sense of community, she said. But since construction began, its served as a thoroughfare for heavy machinery and speeding cars, they said. It helps to overcome differences and share experiences, and it . What minor cracks shes seen dont match settlement problems shes seen in homes elsewhere in the state by any stretch of the imagination, she said. Throughout this 15-year redevelopment, Gold Hill Mesa has grown into a strong and vibrant community, which is key to our mission of taking this long-dormant and blighted property and improving it through a responsible environmental clean-up plan. Complete with maintenance-free living, award winning model homes, green spaces, a fitness center, a spa, and magnificent views of Pikes Peak, Gold Hill Mesa pairs its many community amenities with the traditional comforts of home. Cosmetic cracking does not imply structural damage.. Location Colorado Springs, Colorado Website goldhillmesa.com Next Project Previous Project So far, we havent had further flooding in our basement. In light of the impasse between state geologists and the developer, Colorado Springs planners and engineers have, for now, prevented work from beginning on the newest phase (Filing 11) of the development. Installed new pad and carpet in the basement. Access all of our premium content, get unlimited digital access and more! Three inches of settlement is substantial, said William Hoyt, a certified professional geologist and recently retired professor of geography and oceanography at the University of Northern Colorado. By Kim Washburn. Then people would know if that soil is the same as ours.. Aside from traffic concerns, the group worries more about runoff from Gold Hill Mesa. That report, obtained by The Gazette, contains an itemized list of nearly 50 problems that Clemens, lead inspector for Encompass Home Warranty Inspections, discovered in the home. Fans will get to enjoy even more adventures as Season 4 returns. Somethings shifting here, he said. Installed new base and casing in the basement. You actually know each other compared to other neighborhoods., Of course, every buyer has their own objectives, has their own requirements and they make their own decisions, Haynie said. Theyre gonna build it up so high, whats going to happen when it rains a lot, the waters going to take the path of least resistance, Phillips said. If a buildings being built, itd show really aggressive movement and its off the charts, its an anomaly., Whats left, Lovekin said, is a pattern of subsidence that appears to coincide with the mill tailings pile under the development.. Many of these homes have been built in the last 10 years, with a median sales price of $340,000. Clemens said he found no foundation problems at another house on Eclipse Drive but noticed movement in the yard. And it raises concerns for the future of homes there. Conventional on-the-ground surveys conducted at the site suggest a normal amount of land movement for a residential development, Hoffmann said. 642. But the developer and many Gold Hill Mesa residents push back strongly against the notion that sinking has occurred in the area. This only happens when we have runoff and our streets are flooded. I love to garden. When Gold Hill Mesa submitted the development plan for Filing 11, CGS raised questions. Crews responded to Millstream Terrace again in June 2018, and work orders from the utility indicate they discovered water surfacing from multiple areas in the street and grass. The crews determined that leak could stem from groundwater and a small leak in the water line there, which was repaired.

Cigna Work From Home Salary, Are Shane And Shane Married, Jack Fisher Obituary, Articles G

gold hill mesa sinking

gold hill mesa sinking